Where Science and Faith Converge
Reflections

An Intellectual Code of Conduct, Part 2

By Kenneth R. Samples - May 9, 2012
More

Wild goose chase, rabbit trail, red herring—all these idioms refer to diversionary tactics. A mystery writer might use a red herring character to distract readers (and even the detective) from the real culprit.blog__inline—an-intellectual-code-of-conduct-part-2 A good plot device for authors, but in logic, using a red herring is a fallacy.

Continuing this series on applying the Golden Rule to intellectual arguments, I present a second rule for ensuring civil discourse in all areas of debate.

Rule #2: Stay On Topic When Offering a Legitimate Rebuttal

The red herring fallacy is closely associated with the straw man error (part 1). An arguer commits the red herring mistake, whether on purpose or accidentally, by diverting attention from the real issue at hand and focusing on extraneous or secondary matters. As with the straw man fallacy, a change in subject (even if subtle) results in a loss of logical relevance on an unproductive side trail.

Diversionary tactics such as the red herring violate the “appropriate response” principle—a critic’s responsibility to focus any critique or rebuttal on the real question at hand. We can avoid the red herring fallacy and remind ourselves and our opponent of the debate’s authentic core by asking questions, such as:

  • “Remind me, again, of your argument’s central point.”
  • “How does your current point relate to the overarching issue?”
  • “Can you help me understand the specific support for your conclusion?”

These types of questions can help everyone refocus their thinking and can return the discussion to the original issue.

Check back next week for a third intellectual code of conduct.


Category
  • Ethics
Tags
  • Blogs

About Reasons to Believe

RTB's mission is to spread the Christian Gospel by demonstrating that sound reason and scientific research—including the very latest discoveries—consistently support, rather than erode, confidence in the truth of the Bible and faith in the personal, transcendent God revealed in both Scripture and nature. Learn More »

Support Reasons to Believe

Your support helps more people find Christ through sharing how the latest scientific discoveries affirm our faith in the God of the Bible.

Donate Now

U.S. Mailing Address
818 S. Oak Park Rd.
Covina, CA 91724
  • P (855) 732-7667
  • P (626) 335-1480
  • Fax (626) 852-0178



Reasons to Believe logo

Reasons to Believe is a nonprofit organization designated as tax-exempt under Section 501(c)3 by the Internal Revenue Service. Donations are tax-deductible to the full extent of the law. Our tax ID is #33-0168048. All Transactions on our Web site are safe and secure.

Copyright 2020. Reasons to Believe. All rights reserved. Use of this website constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy.